Skip to content

An Autistic Activist Responds To Temple Grandin

January 30, 2014
by
grandin1

A cow caught in the center track restrainer of a Temple Grandin livestock handling system.



OC Comment: Temple Grandin is a welfarist who designs slaughterhouses meant to lessen the stress on animals.  Rather than maintaining that killing animals is altogether wrong, as an abolitionist does, Ms. Grandin instead attempts to diminish the stress of the killing “experience” on animals.  This is an essay written in opposition of such.

The following essay was written by autistic author, activist and co-founder of Autism Network International, Jim Sinclair. Sinclair noted that he wrote this in “response to Temple Grandin’s writing about her work in the slaughter industry, especially as described in Thinking In Pictures.”

If you love something, you don’t kill it. I didn’t need to spend time in a squeeze box to learn that. Love is not killing.

If you know what another being feels–not just how you feel when you touch it–then you know that living things want to remain alive. It doesn’t matter if they’re not afraid of death before they know what’s going to happen to them. In the moment when the killing happens, they know, and they want to stay alive. I have seen this, and I have felt death happen. I haven’t seen as much of death as someone who is obsessively drawn to slaughter factories, but I’ve seen enough to know. Life does not consent to be killed. I don’t need a Ph.D. in animal science to recognize that.

Dying as a natural process is not the same as killing a healthy living creature. I have witnessed sudden death from injury, and gradual death from aging or disease. They’re not the same. (I have not witnessed deliberately inflicted death, because I will not stand by and allow killing to happen in my presence.) It’s irrelevant if a middle-aged scientist can say that she doesn’t fear death, that she understands it as a natural part of life. Almost all the beings whose lives she helps end are immature or just barely mature. Almost none of them are close to natural death. They’re not ready to die. If someone were to shoot or stab or electrocute the middle-aged scientist today, she might find that she’s not ready to die either.

If you understand life, you know that it wants to continue. If you feel life throbbing under your touch, you know it’s desecration to set your hand to stop that living pulse. If you love something, you don’t kill it.

There’s a special technique involved in tying a hangman’s noose so the victim is killed instantly by a broken neck, rather than slowly by strangulation. I suppose it’s part of a hangman’s professional expertise to learn to tie this knot properly. That expertise doesn’t make the hangman a caring or compassionate person.

The hangman’s knot, the guillotine, the electric chair, the gas chamber, and the lethal injection were all designed to make deliberately inflicted death less painful to the victim. But I’ve never heard the inventors or the users of these technologies hailed as great humanitarians. I’ve never heard them praised for their great empathy toward the lives they’ve ended.

Certainly it takes some ingenuity to invent new equipment. I’m a pretty smart person, but my expertise with knots is limited to being able to tie my shoes, to make a slip knot and a square knot. I tie these knots the way others taught me to tie them; I’ve never invented a new kind of knot by myself. If I were to try to design a knot that could quickly and painlessly kill someone, I’d never be able to figure it out. Whoever invented that knot had a type of mechanical creativity and skill that I don’t have.

But if I did have it, I’d use it for other purposes. I wouldn’t need to invent a way to kill with a knot, because I would never be willing to participate in any way in killing a bound and defenseless person. Skill and ingenuity are not the same as empathy and caring.

And love is not the same thing as killing. If you love something, you don’t kill it. It’s as simple as that.


Order a FREE vegan kit: http://www.peta.org/living/vegetarian-living/free-vegetarian-starter-kit.aspx

Take PETA’s Cruelty-Free Shopping Guide along with you next time you head to the store! The handy guide will help you find humane products at a glance. Order a FREE copy HERE

Want to do more than go vegan? Help others to do so! Click on the below for nominal, or no, fees to vegan literature that you can use to convince others that veganism is the only compassionate route to being an animal friend.

PETA: http://www.petacatalog.com/catalog/Literature-39-1.html

Action for Animals has a very low price : http://store.afa-online.org/home.php?cat=284

Have questions? Click HERE

Humane slaughter an oxmoron foul.
Pain is pain, whether or not there
Is a howl.
Tools of killing, however euphemized…
Will not quell the terror or silence
The cries.

Karen Lyons Kalmenson


16 Comments leave one →
  1. lovegan permalink
    January 30, 2014 1:07 pm

    Thanks a million Stacey !!! I’ll share with a warning: *tissues needed*.

    Like

  2. karenlyonskalmenson permalink
    January 30, 2014 1:24 pm

    Humane slaughter an oxmoron foul.
    Pain is pain, whether or not there
    Is a howl.
    Tools of killing, however euphemized…
    Will not quell the terror or silence
    The cries.

    Like

    • January 30, 2014 2:06 pm

      Perfect as always, thanks, wonderful poet.

      Like

      • karenlyonskalmenson permalink
        January 30, 2014 2:15 pm

        you are so very welcome and thank you, sweet, compassionate soul.

        Like

  3. January 30, 2014 1:36 pm

    NEVER EVER IN A MILLION YEARS IS IT OK TO KILL A LIVING BREATHING SENTIENT ANIMAL ! I CAN’T COMPREHEND THIS AT ALL . IT’S ALL VILE CRUEL DISGRACEFUL AND WRONG. TO INFLICT FEAR AND PAIN AND TORTURE TO ANY ANIMAL IS NO DIFFERENT FROM DOING THE SAME TO A CHILD !

    Like

  4. January 30, 2014 2:12 pm

    Beautifully written. And I have to say, I dislike Temple Grandin very much — always have. I have never bought into her “more humane/less painful/frightening to the animals BS.

    Like

  5. January 30, 2014 2:13 pm

    Reblogged this on Girl for Animal Liberation.

    Like

  6. mark gillono permalink
    January 30, 2014 2:24 pm

    great article and all too true. i never understood how anyone who cares anything about non-human animals could consider Grandin anything more than the cold, unfeeling paid killer which she is. what would we have thought of the person who designed the gas chambers at concentration camps to be “slightly” less cruel? the only problem i have with the wording is that “If you love something, you don’t kill it.” should read “if you love SOMEONE, you don’t kill THEM” . “something” and “it” imply an inanimate object and not a living, feeling sentient being.

    Like

  7. January 30, 2014 10:15 pm

    ils tuent des animaux d’une manière cruelle, il faut que cela cesse.

    Like

  8. January 30, 2014 10:15 pm

    Reblogged this on "OUR WORLD".

    Like

  9. Teresa permalink
    January 22, 2016 4:01 pm

    Bravo! I was always dismayed by her work getting positive attention.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Jet Eliot

Travel and Wildlife Adventures

Organic Opinion

Finding it, aye there's the rub~

The Year(s) of Living Non-Judgmentally

Here and now, with all of it.

Eat No Harm

Living consciously for our planet, the animals, and ourselves.

Flawless Pandemonium

Question everything~

Veganism is Nonviolence

Being Vegan Is A First Step To A Nonviolent Life

The Biotrotter

The Globetrotting Biologists

Sophie's Foodie Files

Mostly healthy tasty colorful cooking & gardening with Sophie's twist!

Let Me Reach with Kim Saeed

Narcissistic Abuse Support | Maintaining No Contact | Heal Grow Evolve

Steal This Meme

humans' vegan past & future. SHIRIN - Subvert Human Irrationalities, Rediscover Innate Nature

Gillian Prew // poetry

for the earth and the animals

Nepali Today

Coffee break Photo Blogs Base In Tokyo, Japan.

veganomics

making the link between our food, our health, our society, our environment and our economy

Friendly Fairy Tales

Fairy Tales and Poetry Celebrating Magic and Nature for Kids of all Ages

Arcilla y fuego

Una visión sobre el complejo y apasionante mundo de la cerámica

Gotta Find a Home

Conversations with Street People

%d bloggers like this: